Culloden《可落登战役》

史地类纪录片,BBC 频道 1964 年出品。

Culloden_cover0.jpg

暂无

  • 中文片名 :可落登战役
  • 中文系列名:
  • 英文片名 :Culloden
  • 英文系列名:
  • 电视台 :BBC
  • 地区 :英国
  • 语言 :英語
  • 版本 :TV
  • 发行时间 :1964

The film uses a pseudo-documentary style, recreating the events of the Battle of Culloden with historical accuracy but presenting the action as if the filmmakers are contemporaries of 1746. They use a fly-on-the-wall approach to filming and conduct fictional vox pop interviews with the protagonists from both sides. In using this approach the director, Peter Watkins, practically invents the genre of the drama documentary which is so in evidence right up to the present day.

As the film opens it is clear that the Clan army under Bonnie Prince Charlie are emphatically the underdogs. They suffer from hunger, fatigue and depleted numbers. Moreover, they have an inadequate battle strategy, the Prince favouring the advice of vain Irishman John O’Sullivan over Lord George Murray, their most effective General. The depiction of the battle scenes are graphic and capture the devastation among the Clan army, illustrating the incompetence of their leadership. Among its many statistics, the film states that within one hour and eight minutes, the Scottish Pretender lost approximately 1200 men to the English’s 50.

The remainder of the film shows the English army conducting a vicious program of ethnic cleansing in the Highlands with the aid of the Scottish lowland army. It also describes how the clans were abandoned by their Prince. He sought exile in Europe, taking the remaider of the Jacobite funds and dismissing his army. The filmmakers decribe the consequences of the defeat, stating that the centuries to follow witnessed the pacification of the Highlands. The English government penalised clan culture and introduced sheep to the area, eventually displacing the people to Canada and Australia. They conclude by saying that the English ‘created a desert and called it peace’.

I would advise watching this as a part of a triumvirate broadcast that night on BBC4: it’s companion piece from 1996 about the making of Culloden (http://thebox.bz/details.php?id=90257 ) and from 2006 The Battle That Made Britain (http://thebox.bz/details.php?id=90290 ) about the impact of Culloden on the development of Britain in the 18th Century and on up to the present day.

Culloden_screen1.jpg

暂无

内容 社会科学类 军事 近代战争
史地类 历史 十八世纪

暂无

Category:片名 Category:BBC Category:1964 Category:5. 社会科学类 Category:5.6 军事 Category:5.613 近代战争 Category:6. 史地类 Category:6.1 历史 Category:6.115 十八世纪 Category:6.2 地理 Category:6.23 欧洲 Category:6.231 西欧 Category:6.2311 英国 Category:缺翻译